Do Payday Loans “Victimize” People?

April 24, 2007

I’m pretty sure I have made my stance clear on payday loans. They’re expensive and I hate ’em. That said, I do take issue with an editorial (pdf) I read today in my local paper. The piece was written by Don Baylor who is a senior policy analyst at the Center for Public Policy Priorities. Here’s the part of his editorial that bugs me:

Nationwide, many workers are falling victim to “payday” loans—short-term loans that give workers a cash advance on their paychecks. Large numbers of military families use these loans to help make ends meet between pay periods. So do millions of low- and middle-income people across the country. The problem is that these loans come with a major catch—exorbitant interest rates that begin at 400 percent Annual Percentage Rate (APR) and can surpass 1,000%.

It is typical for a worker to pay $180 in interest on a 10-day, $700 loan.

These high interest rates make it nearly impossible for workers to repay the loan on time, causing many workers to refinance and borrow again just to pay off the interest on the first loan. One emergency can lead to a debt spiral, as borrowers take out an average of nine loans per year. The result? More loans, more debt, and more bankruptcies.

Like I said, I hate payday loans. But, why is it that every time there’s a problem, it’s always because people are victims of something? What the heck happened to personal responsibility? If people are victims of anything, it’s their own lack of sound judgement. Seriously, if people didn’t use payday loans there wouldn’t be payday loan companies.

I think the number one problem in our country right now is the victim mentality!

55 responses to Do Payday Loans “Victimize” People?

  1. I think payday loans are perfectly fine. Everyone says interest rates are bad.

    I have a bank of america credit card – my interest rate is 30% and that is still perfectly legal for them to do. Interest rates on payday loans never come close to that!

Trackbacks and Pingbacks:

  1. Do Payday Loans “Victimize” People? at Bankruptcy Law Network - Real Lawyers, Real Solutions - April 26, 2007

    […] Over at AllFinancialMatters, a post about personal responsibility when it comes to payday loans.  Though the author (someone with whom I usually agree) is clear that he dislikes payday loans, he does say […]

  2. Free Money Finance - April 27, 2007

    Star Money Articles for the Week of April 23

    Here are interesting posts and news this week from the MoneyBlogNetwork members and beyond: Consumerism Commentary says he buys generic and store brands sometimes. AllFinancialMatters asks if payday loans victimize people. MightyBargainHunter details h…

  3. » Weekly Blog Roundup on Consumerism Commentary: A Personal Finance Blog - April 27, 2007

    […] Do Payday Loans “Victimize” People? Payday Loans are bad ideas, but are they victimizing customers, or should customers take full responsibility? Responsibility must be shared between companies that should operate in an ethical manner and not take advantage of people in difficult positions, and customers who must be as educated as possible about whatever product or service they’re considering. [AllFinancialMatters] […]

  4. » Brief China Notes and Weekly Roundup  on Blueprint for Financial Prosperity - April 28, 2007

    […] JLP discusses his disdain for both payday loans and the implication that borrowers are victims and not willing participants. I totally agree. […]