By JLP | August 21, 2010
Listen to the first few seconds of this video of President Obama explain the social security situation.
This morning I watched a clip on Fox News (not the above clip) with a panel discussing social security and the above clip of Obama. One of the panelists, a Democratic strategist, talked about means testing social security payments so that the “wealthy” do not receive benefits.
Here is the problem with this idea:
It penalizes those who planned for retirement. There are lots of people out there who are making sacrifices in order to put money aside for retirement. People who are foregoing nice cars, fancy houses, and vacations in order to save for their future. Meanwhile, their neighbors are living the highlife and not saving nearly enough for retirement. Then, retirement day gets here and the one who put money back for retirement is going to have to give up some of their social security and the one who did nothing is going to get their full retirement. Crazy.
I think a fairer way to means test (I’m not saying I agree with means testing) is to means test on career earnings. The Social Security Administration has those earnings records. Yes, those who planned for retirement will still be penalized somewhat but not nearly to the extreme that they would be if the means test was performed on retirement assets.
The same Democratic strategist also talked about the social security trust fund. Is there even a trust fund with actual assets? It doesn’t appear so. According to the linked piece, there is an account filled with IOUs.
If only the government would have structured it as a retirement planning system. There were more than enough current workers to fund benefits for those who were currently retired. The balance could have gone into retirement accounts for the current workers. It should have never become the mess it has become. Yes, I’m angry about this because I know that my generation and my kids’ generation is going to get screwed on this deal.
This is what happens when we allow government to do for us what we should be doing for ourselves.